: Reviewers appreciate the unique world-building and atmospheric setting. However, some critics found the ending too "neat" or rushed and noted that the romance occasionally relies on common YA tropes.
“There is a very good base here, but it needs development... the ending in particular felt somewhat out of place or even illogical.” Steam
: The primary criticism is that the story ends on a massive cliffhanger with many plot holes left unresolved. Although a rewrite was once in progress, many community members consider the project abandoned . The Shadow Society (Novel by Marie Rutkoski)
: Players frequently praise the well-developed characters and the complex romance options, which are often compared to the popular Wayhaven Chronicles . The world-building and diverse customization options are also highlighted as strong points.
“I really liked the characters and the story is interesting so far. I already can't wait till the sequel.” Reddit · r/choiceofgames · 6 years ago
: Follows Darcy Jones, a foster child who discovers she belongs to a race called Shades living in a parallel Chicago where the Great Fire of 1871 never happened.