Crucially, is excluded from both teams, as both Jake and Holt believe she is too compromised by her relationship with Jake and her loyalty to the Captain. The "Amazing Detective/Genius" Twist
, titled " Halloween III ," is widely considered one of the series' most pivotal episodes, as it established the precinct-wide tradition of the Halloween Heist . Plot Overview Brooklyn_nine-nine_3x05
In this third iteration of the annual competition, the stakes are raised beyond the individual rivalry between and Captain Raymond Holt . The challenge is to steal a crown locked in a briefcase in the middle of the precinct. To ensure victory, the duo divides the squad into two competing teams: Team Holt : Terry Jeffords and Gina Linetti. Team Jake : Rosa Diaz and Charles Boyle. Crucially, is excluded from both teams, as both
: Amy successfully steals the crown before either team can secure it, forcing both Jake and Holt to crown her the "Amazing Detective/Genius". The challenge is to steal a crown locked
: The episode highlights the evolving Jake/Amy relationship and the squad's collective competitive spirit. Memorable Moments :