: Shelby witnesses a "hailstorm" of human teeth and is nearly drowned in an outdoor hot tub by unseen figures.
The premiere of American Horror Story: Roanoke , titled "Chapter 1," debuted on September 14, 2016, introducing a radical departure from the series' traditional format by adopting a "show within a show" documentary style. American Horror Story Roanoke - Episode 1
: Dramatizing the events described in the testimonials. Shelby Miller : Played by Sarah Paulson . Matt Miller : Played by Cuba Gooding Jr. . Lee Harris : Played by Angela Bassett . Plot Summary : Shelby witnesses a "hailstorm" of human teeth